I had the same dilemma before my trip, so I did both—and now I can give you a detailed, firsthand breakdown to help you decide which one fits your style, interests, and travel rhythm. Whether you care more about beaches, food, transport, or just the overall feel, this guide covers everything you need to know.
Getting There: Ferry or Flight?
Both Paros and Naxos are well-connected to Athens and other Cycladic islands, and you have two main ways to get there: by ferry or by plane. The ferries are scenic but often chaotic. On both islands, I experienced delays and last-minute confusion at the port. Signs were vague or missing, and the boarding process was a bit of a free-for-all. That said, if you’re mentally prepared and arrive early, you should be fine.
If you want a smoother experience, both Paros and Naxos have small airports with direct flights from Athens. These flights are short (about 40 minutes) and are a great option if you’re tight on time or don’t want to deal with unpredictable ferry schedules.
First Impressions
Paros felt calm—almost too calm. When I arrived, the downtown area looked built for tourism, but it was oddly quiet. Even at lunchtime, many restaurants were still serving breakfast. It almost felt like I arrived before the island was ready for me. Naxos, on the other hand, instantly felt alive. From the minute I stepped off the boat, there was a buzz in the air. People were walking along the port, shops were open, and everything looked more colorful and dynamic.
Things to Do and See
Paros has its charms, but you really need to plan ahead. The island has great beaches, like Kolymbithres and Santa Maria, and cute villages like Lefkes. But getting to most of these spots requires either a car or some coordination with buses or taxi boats. If you just show up without a plan or vehicle, you might find yourself doing laps around the main town, like I did.
Naxos is bigger, and there’s a lot more to explore—but surprisingly, much of it is accessible by public bus. I managed to visit mountain villages like Apeiranthos, hike Mount Zas, and chill at Alyko Beach all without renting a car. There’s also the Temple of Apollo right near the port, and Plaka Beach is an easy bus ride away. If you’re up for exploring, Naxos offers more variety within reach.
Beaches
Paros has some stunning beaches, and many of them are relatively easy to reach if you stay near Parikia or Naoussa. Kolymbithres Beach is a favorite, known for its unique rock formations and shallow waters. You can get there by taxi boat from Naoussa, which is a fun and easy option. Santa Maria is another great beach with clear water and more of a lively vibe—ideal if you’re into beach bars and some water sports. If you’re willing to travel a bit farther, Golden Beach and Faragas Beach offer wider stretches of sand and fewer crowds.
Naxos takes things up a notch with its beach game. Plaka Beach is arguably one of the best in the Cyclades—long, sandy, and not overly developed, with enough cafes and tavernas to keep you fed and happy all day. Agios Prokopios and Agia Anna are more organized and very accessible by bus. If you’re willing to venture out a bit more (and maybe rent a car for a day), Alyko Beach with its cedar forest and raw, untouched landscape is truly special. Naxos also has more hidden beaches and coves for the adventurous types, especially along the west and east coasts.
Getting Around: Do You Need a Car?
You don’t necessarily need a car in Paros. I know that might be surprising, but the bus network is actually quite good—especially if you stay in Parikia or Naoussa. Buses are frequent, affordable, and connect most key spots. Plus, you can bike, walk, or even hop on a taxi boat to reach places like Kolymbithres Beach or Marcelo Beach. Just be mindful that in shoulder season, bus frequencies drop a bit.
Naxos is the largest of the Cyclades, and while the bus system is reliable, it’s more spread out. If you stay near the port and stick to popular destinations, you’ll be fine. But if you want to explore more remote beaches or smaller villages off the beaten path, renting a car for at least a day or two is a good idea. It just gives you the flexibility to go where buses don’t reach or when they aren’t running often enough.
Food and Local Experience
If food is a big part of your travel experience, Naxos will blow you away. It’s known for its meats, cheeses, and hearty traditional dishes. I had unforgettable meals here: the Poseidon pasta at Nikos & Maria in Plaka with shrimp, mussels, and ouzo-tomato sauce was incredible. So was the squid ink risotto at Su e Giu, and the Rosto (slow-cooked pork) at Maro’s in the main town. For veggie options, try the zucchini fritters at Irini’s or the eggplant rolls with Naxian graviera at Platia in Galini.
Paros has great food too, but it’s a bit more understated. You’ll find Cycladic classics like onion fritters, chickpeas slow-cooked in clay pots, and roasted goat with herbs and rice (patoudo). The flavors are rustic and traditional. It’s definitely satisfying, but the food scene isn’t as diverse or vibrant as Naxos.
Accommodation and Prices
In terms of where to stay, both islands offer a good mix of budget and luxury options, but prices skew higher in Paros. Paros has about 2,110 hotels listed. The average 3-star hotel goes for around €94.94 per night. A 4-star room costs roughly €207.07, and 5-star options average €349.39.
Naxos is a bit easier on the wallet. It has around 1,941 hotels. You can find a 3-star stay for about €93.95 per night. A 4-star hotel will cost you around €155.98, and 5-star stays average €285.14. If you want comfort without stretching your budget too far, Naxos gives you more bang for your buck.
Final Thoughts: Paros or Naxos?
If you want a laid-back vibe, beautiful beaches, and don’t mind planning things in advance, Paros could be a great choice—especially if you’re staying for several days and have time to slow down. Just know that you’ll need to be a bit more proactive with logistics.
If you’re after a richer experience, easier access to diverse landscapes, incredible food, and more spontaneity in your day-to-day exploring, I’d recommend Naxos. It just felt more alive, more authentic, and more varied.
Paros vs Naxos
| Paros | Naxos | |
|---|---|---|
| Transport Options | Ferry and flights; ferry can be chaotic | Ferry and flights; ferry can be chaotic |
| First Impressions | Calm, quiet, touristy but low-energy | Vibrant, engaging, lively atmosphere |
| Things to Do | Requires planning; many spots need car or boat | More variety; most highlights reachable by bus |
| Beaches | Scenic but more spaced out; requires transport | More varied and accessible; standout beaches everywhere |
| Getting Around | Excellent public buses; no car needed if planned | Bus system works well; car helps for remote areas |
| Food | Traditional, rustic Cycladic cuisine | Diverse, flavorful, meat and cheese specialties |
| Accommodation | More hotels but pricier overall | Slightly fewer hotels, more affordable mid to high range |
| Best For | Relaxed trips, longer stays, planners | Explorers, foodies, spontaneous travelers |
| Car Necessity | Optional, thanks to good buses and bike/taxi options | Not essential, but useful for in-depth exploration |
More Paros and Naxos posts you might be interested:
